Skip to main

Best Mexican food in Caldwell

A Coastal-Inspired Mexican Restaurant with A Laid-Back Vibe

Blackened Bowl

Blackened Bowl
Dive into bold flavors with our Blackened Bowl: tender Blackened Sole atop a vibrant mix of red cabbage, fresh pico de gallo, creamy crema, and zesty chipotle aioli. Served with rice and beans, it's a coastal-inspired dish that hits every craving. Perfect for taco lovers looking to mix it up!

Nachos

Nachos
Get ready to crunch into perfection! Our Nachos feature crispy corn chips piled high with black beans, melted mixed cheddar cheese, fresh guacamole, zesty pico de gallo, creamy Mexican crema, and tangy pickled jalapeños. A crowd-pleaser that's a nacho-average snack!

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Baja Taco

Tempura battered cod, green cabbage, lime cilantro sauce, pico de gallo, and flour tortilla

Add Item

Blackened Taco

Blackened sole, red cabbage, crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo, and flour tortilla

Add Item

Lobster Taco

Lobster meat, old bay aioli, green cabbage, fresh chives, and 6" flour tortilla

Add Item

Pork Belly Bowl

Braised pork belly, white rice, black beans, chili-dusted caramelized pineapple, pickled red onions, queso fresco cheese, and chipotle salsa

Add Item

Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken, chihuahua cheese, jalapenos, and cilantro in a flour tortilla

Add Item

Spicy Shrimp Taco

Spicy Shrimp Taco
Turn up the heat with our Spicy Shrimp Taco! Juicy grilled shrimp paired with crisp red cabbage, creamy poblano avocado sauce, fresh pico de gallo, and a peppery arugula garnish. All wrapped in a soft flour tortilla for the perfect bite every time.
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Are you craving tacos, bowls, or something spicy? Skip the line and order your favorites online! From bold flavors to fresh ingredients, your next meal is just a click away. Treat yourself to the coastal vibes—anytime, anywhere.

Taste the Coast

Feast your eyes on a gallery of our vibrant, flavor-packed dishes—each one crafted with fresh ingredients and a dash of coastal flair. Dive in and discover your next favorite bite! 🌊🌮

Welcome to Fat Fish Taco

Welcome to Fat Fish Taco
Where coastal vibes meet bold Mexican flavors! 🌴🌮 Whether you're here for a quick bite, family dinner, or Taco Tuesday vibes every day, we’ve got something fresh and delicious waiting for you. Relax out front or take the flavors to-go. Dive into the Fat Fish experience today!

Healthy & Delicious, Every Bite

Healthy & Delicious, Every Bite
At Fat Fish Taco, we believe healthy food doesn't have to compromise on flavor! Our menu is packed with vibrant, fresh ingredients—perfectly balanced to nourish and satisfy. From grilled shrimp and blackened soles to colorful veggies and zesty sauces, every dish is crafted with care to give you a meal that’s as delicious as it is wholesome. Enjoy coastal-inspired dishes that are both flavorful and good for you!

Let Fat Fish Taco Cater Your Next Event!

Let Fat Fish Taco Cater Your Next Event!
Planning a party, office lunch, or special celebration? Let us bring the flavor to you! From our signature tacos to our delicious bowls, we offer catering that’s perfect for any occasion. Whether you're feeding a small group or a big crowd, we’ve got you covered with fresh, vibrant dishes everyone will love. Reach out today to make your event unforgettable with Fat Fish Taco!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Fresh food and amazing staff. We were looking for a new spot for some street food (tacos) and we were half we tried this place. Warm welcome when we came in we ordered the Beef Nachos they were stacked high and the beef was very tender.

Justin D.

Justin D.

Love the place. The food is soo delicious yet healthy. Service is outstanding and super friendly. Great value to boot. Must try.

Samer G.

Samer G.

Incredibly delicious tacos! Don't expect only the usual Mexican fare, although they have that too. The chef and owner, Steve Benyo, creates tacos with a great array of diverse flavors.

Norman M.

Norman M.

Featuring

Catering

Delivery

Take Out

Dine In

Kids Menu

Join the Fat Fish Taco Rewards!

Join the Fat Fish Taco Rewards!

Want to score free food and exclusive deals? Sign up for our rewards program and start earning points every time you dine with us! It’s quick, easy, and totally worth it. Get rewarded for enjoying the tacos, bowls, and all your favorites. Sign up today and treat yourself to some tasty perks!

Frequently asked questions

We are known for Shrimp, Nachos, Quesadilla, Tacos, Taco, and Burritos

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in Caldwell, NJ at 291 Bloomfield Ave

Our location